INDEMNITY ALERT- ‘Car finance cases: hazard warning lights are flashing’

31 July 2025 by Daniel Kellard

Insights/INDEMNITY ALERT- ‘Car finance cases: hazard warning lights are flashing’
Authors:
INDEMNITY ALERT- ‘Car finance cases: hazard warning lights are flashing’

4:35pm. That is the rather interesting time that the Supreme Court is handing down its judgment in the eagerly anticipated and far reaching car finance cases. The Supreme Court usually hands down decisions at 9:45am, which leads one to speculate that the 4:35pm timing (ahead of a weekend) has been chosen a) to avoid any immediate impact on the share price of the lenders that would be impacted by the judgment, and/or b) to allow the industry the weekend to digest the decision. The Supreme Court has been quick to note that no inference should be drawn from the timing of the handing down of the judgment as to the outcome of the appeals.

Besides the banks, the judgment is of major interest to many, including but not limited to, other brokers outside the car financing space, the FCA, and the Treasury. It has been reported that the Chancellor Rachel Reeves is considering whether to introduce legislation with retrospective effect to curb the impact of the judgment, both on car financing claims, and other areas with similar commission structures. This comes after the Supreme Court had previously rejected the Treasury’s attempt to intervene in the appeal in February.

Set your alarms for 4:35pm, Friday 1 August!

In order to bring you up to speed, we set out below the findings from the Court of Appeal judgment.

The Court of Appeal Judgment

On 25 October 2024 the Court of Appeal handed down its judgment on three cases heard together, namely Johnson v Firstrand Bank Ltd, Wrench v Firstrand Bank Ltd, and Hopcraft v Close Brothers Ltd. These cases concerned the legitimacy of commissions paid by the lender (in each case the defendant/respondent in the above cases) to the car finance dealer when consumers purchased a car on finance.

The judgment can be found here.

The car dealers (who sold the cars to the lender, with the lender then entering into the financing agreement with the consumer/purchaser) were the sellers of the cars, but also acted as credit brokers on behalf of the purchaser/claimant. As such, the dealers owed the claimants a “disinterested duty” (to provide advice/information on an impartial basis) and a fiduciary duty. It is important to note that all three of the credit agreements concerned were made prior to the FCA’s regulatory changes of January 2021, which banned the use of Difference in Charge (‘DIC’) commission models (arrangements that were the subject of these three cases), and were widely used between 2007 and 2021.

The court found in all three cases there was a conflict of interest and no informed consent on the part of the consumer purchaser to the receipt of commission by the car dealer from the lender. The nature of the lenders exposure depends on the extent to which the commission is disclosed to the purchaser. If the commission paid is secret (no disclosure), the lender has primary liability, whereas if there is partial disclosure (which suffices to negate secrecy), the lender can only be held liable in equity as an accessory to the breach of fiduciary duty by the car dealer/broker. In essence however, in all three cases the remedy was the same, namely repayment of the commissions to the purchaser.

In  Hopcraft  there was no disclosure of the commission.  In Wrench the court found there was insufficient disclosure of the commission to the underlying purchaser. In both cases, therefore, the commission was secret  and the lenders were found to be liable as primary wrongdoers.

In the Johnson case, there was held to be sufficient disclosure of the commission so that it was not secret, but insufficient disclosure to get the consumer’s fully informed consent to the payment of the commission. Therefore, the claimant was held to be entitled to receive equitable compensation from Firstrand for its accessory liability for procuring the dealers breach of fiduciary duty.[1]

Who is exposed?

Lenders

Depending on what the Supreme Court decides, lenders involved in the car financing space will need to make (perhaps even further) provision in their balance sheet for upcoming liabilities, and shareholders may be concerned if such provision was not made, with the possibility of actions arising against companies who knew about potential liabilities but did not adequately plan for them.

Lenders since the Court of Appeal judgment will no doubt have been looking at their credit agreements and the wording about commissions, and ensuring going forward that fully informed consent is obtained, as regards other types of commission arrangements beyond those banned by the FCA in 2021. A statement in the terms and conditions of a credit agreement between a lender and a consumer that commission may or will be paid will not necessarily negate secrecy (satisfy the disclosure burden), if it is buried in small print and not brought to the attention of the consumer.

Car dealers

Car dealers, although not the defendant’s in these combined cases, are very much now under the microscope, with their fiduciary duties examined in the judgment. Car dealers could face direct claims from purchasers, or be brought into actions to which lenders are a part.

The Supreme Court hearing

The appeal was heard over three days in April 2025, namely 1-3 April inclusive. In brief summary (noting the judgment will clarify issues this Friday, and so pre-empting such findings is of little utility), arguments were heard from the FCA, motor finance providers, consumers, and the National Franchised Dealers Association (NFDA).

Most notable perhaps was the FCA’s written submissions which argued that the Court went too far by treating motor dealer brokers as owing fiduciary duties, and noted that the ‘unfairness’ of commission arrangements as regards S140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 may depend on various factors, including the size of the commission, its nature, and how it was disclosed to the consumer.

Applications to intervene were refused from numerous bodies, most notably the Treasury. It has been reported that the Chancellor Rachel Reeves is considering whether to introduce legislation with retrospective effect to curb the impact of the judgment, both on car financing claims, and other areas with similar commission structures.

We await the Supreme Court judgment this Friday 1 August 2025, at 4:35pm.

[1] In the Johnson case also, the court considered a statutory claim under s140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 and found there to be an unfair relationship due to the high commission charged on the deal, namely 25% of the sum advanced to the consumer, and the lack of disclosure to the consumer of the arrangement with the dealer broker.